Here it is: the master list of every game that's been reviewed on this site.
2001 IF Competition Reviews
2004 IF Competition Reviews
2005 IF Competition Reviews
9:05
Above and Beyond!
ADRIFT Games
Adventures of Helpfulman
Anchorhead
Augmented Fourth
Bugged
Chico and I Ran
Common Ground
Dangerous Curves
Dino-Comp Games
Dutch Dapper IV
EnvComp
FailSafe
Fallacy of Dawn
The Fire Tower
The Frenetic Five vs. Mr. Redundancy Man
Future Boy!
Heroine's Mantle
IF Arcade Games
Inform School
Inheritance
Introcomp 2005
Introcomp 2006
LASH
Life on GUE Street
Lost
Lost in New York
The Mulldoon Legacy
Not Just a Game
Nothing More, Nothing Less
Not Just an Ordinary Ballerina
Offensive Probing
Once and Future
Photopia
Reverzi
Romance Novel Comp 2002 Games
A Simple Theft
Shareware Registration Feelies
Shrapnel
SmoochieComp 2001 Games
TelegramComp Games
Textfire Golf
ToasterComp Games
Vadventure
Winchester's Nightmare
Winter Wonderland
Worlds Apart